The Get Up crew react to the New York Giants not drafting J.J. McCarthy and talk through the Draft winners and losers after Round 1. Then, the panel debate if the Buffalo Bills are failing Josh Allen by not selecting a first-round WR.
Drake Maye as a Fit for the Patriots:
- The Patriots struggled significantly with their offensive line protection last season, leading to difficulties for their quarterbacks and running backs.
- Drake M’s combination of physical talent, intelligence, work ethic, and character make him an attractive prospect for a team looking to develop a quarterback for the future.
- Sitting behind Jacoby Brissett, who has experience as a starter, would provide Drake M with valuable mentorship and development opportunities without the immediate pressure to perform.
B Knicks as an Ideal Fit for the Broncos:
- The Broncos have been searching for a long-term solution at quarterback since the departure of Peyton Manning, and B Knicks offers promising qualities for their offense.
- B Knicks’ accuracy and quick processing abilities make him a strong candidate to lead an offense effectively, especially under the guidance of a coach like Shawn Payton.
- Denver’s offensive system, which may emphasize quick decision-making and precision passing, aligns well with B Knicks’ strengths, setting him up for success in the Mile High City.
JJ McCarthy’s Skills and Fit with the Vikings:
- JJ McCarthy’s mastery of play-action passing and his ability to read defenses make him an intriguing prospect for a team like the Vikings, who utilize play-action heavily in their offensive scheme.
- McCarthy’s understanding of defensive coverages and his knack for making accurate throws under pressure align well with the demands of Minnesota’s offense under head coach Kevin O’Kono.
- With the Vikings’ emphasis on incorporating multiple layers of the defense into their passing game, McCarthy’s ability to anticipate and exploit defensive weaknesses could be a valuable asset for the team.
Giants’ Decision to Pass on McCarthy:
- The Giants’ decision not to draft McCarthy raises questions about their confidence in Daniel Jones as the long-term solution at quarterback.
- Despite McCarthy’s potential to bring explosive plays to the offense, the Giants opted to address other needs, such as adding playmakers like Malik Neighbors.
- However, concerns remain about Jones’ inconsistency and injury history, leading some analysts, including Orlovsky, to believe that McCarthy would have been a better investment for the team’s future success.
Assessment of Winners and Losers from the Draft:
- The Chicago Bears emerged as clear winners of the draft by securing a highly regarded quarterback in the first round, providing hope for a franchise that has struggled at the position in recent years.
- While the Buffalo Bills’ lack of a first-round pick may initially seem like a setback, Orlovsky argues that their decision to trade down and acquire more picks demonstrates a strategic approach to building roster depth and addressing multiple needs.
- Despite missing out on potential impact players in the first round, the Bills have ample opportunities to add talent in later rounds and via trades, positioning themselves for long-term success.